I think we'll probably end up doing Blue Water Grill. It's easier for everyone to walk to from the Catholic church rather than taking cabs to Casa Picasso...price wise, it was about the same...BWG about 10% higher.
Sunset cruise is a nice idea, but I don't want to either tell people to not go on trips that day or run out of daylight on the water. Just easier to do a restaurant so we can be flexible with the time.