I get a laugh at every one of these "Where's a good place to eat?" questions from the newbies. I think if you listed every single eating place on the small island you could find at least a dozen boarders who would profess they each are a wonderful place to eat. And as soon as someone writes of an unpleasant experience at a restaurant, those who advocate the place will rush to their defense...and then there's usually a food fight...etc. Congratulations to all who decided to only mention their pleasant experiences in this thread!
That said, my favorite fancy place to recommend to a newbie would be Capricorn and my favorite casual place would be Pepperoni's pizza and my favorite bar would be Crazy Canuck's...so, Cutie50, I hope you have a chance to try all the wonderful places that have been recommended and I suspect you're going to enjoy your culinary experience on the island.