There are six of us (three couples) so if it were totally up to me I would go with a three bedroom, 2 (ideally 3) bathroom place. However one of the couples is celebrating their anniversary and want a bit more privacy. So it looks like a 2br/2bath and a 1br/1bath is what we need. I have heard back from a couple of places but I can't seem to get anyone from the Yacht Club (Island Resorts) to answer my emails.