Sounds like you are just talking about visiting either or both, not moving to, correct?

I've spent a couple months in AC in the last few years, and only a couple days in Placencia so clearly know one better than the other . .

A few things to consider --- are you a diver? Diving is easier and less expensive in AC w/the reef being so close to the land. I dive a lot in AC, didn't dive in Placencia. Are you a sailer? Sailing options seemes abundant in both places.

Getting there --- I drove there last year. . .it was challenging to say the least. I wouldn't do it again. The drive from BC to the Hopkins area is one of my favorite -- love, love, love going through the Maya Mountains. However, once you turn on to the peninsula road to get to Placencia -- it's a dirt road in very ordinary condition. People talked of a road being paved - not sure what road. I can't imagine the whole road in to Placencia being paved as it certainly wasn't a year ago. (road to PG has been paved in the last year) Doing the drive in Oct. was challenging as we had to be aware of possible bridges out, and then a lot of rain filled huge pot holes. I really wanted to leave the rental car in Placencia and fly back because I hated the road that much (ok, I was being sort of wimpy I guess, but it was a tough tough drive.). There is a bus system through Belize although I haven't tried it. I've been told there are a lot of stops and it can take a long time to get places.

I agree with Snoopysmom that Placencia feels more like a beach town. Very laid back - more so than AC forsure, prob comparable to Caye Caulker. Another option less traveled if you want really laid back is Hopkins. It's a super laid back village - small, not a lot of tourists. I'm a hiker so I love Hopkins for its close proximity to a couple great jungle hiking spots. (And it's a 2ish hour drive from BC, Placencia is closer to 4) But Hopkins is no Placencia of AC -- it's tiny tiny. But full of local color. (Like the Lebeha Drumming Center where local Garifuna teens gather for impromptu jam sessions.)

Good luck! You're considering a couple fabulous spots - I'm sure you will make the decision that's right for you and have a great time! smile

Sheryl