I've found square copper nails and old bottles at the streach of beach from big daddys to tackel box, but that area has been the islands central dock area for centurys. Its where ships pulled up to repair and central location of island James Howard Blakes Dock in the 1800's.
Richie Woods drew a map of The Tres Coco's wreck and it was fun to search there until Keith . I would find Delft China (broken),spoons , forks , nails bottles and shot balls. I dont believe in treasure hunting, its a sickness and i try not to spend to much time on it or the lottery.

White Sands Dive Shop
https://whitesandsdiveshop.com/