We did one with Hustler last Jan and it was the hit of our vacation. Fresh fish, fresh conch ceviche, snorkeled, dove, fished. This is definitely going to be repeated each trip. We went north, and had our beach picnic at Basil Jones, probably one of the more beautiful spots on the island. There were 6 of us and we set it up for our own personal day in the sun, no strangers. For a few bucks, they will let you set your own itinerary. It cost us a lot less per person than turning the girls loose for a few hours shopping.

Been there, done that, the washing machine ate the T-shirt