Sweet Jane;

If you were on Ambergris Caye during that very freakish seaweed episode there is NO WAY the beach at Caribe Island wouldn't have smelled of it. It was a most unusual occurrence. Every single beachfront property had the "scent", even those that were raked every HOUR. I like Caribe Island too, but I wouldn't say they were capable of the impossible!

And, just to confirm, the beach at Banyan Bay is one of the nicest. On Sundays it is busy with locals having fun. On other days it is clean, quiet and has good swimming.