I think you would really like Banana Beach and if you enjoyed the private villa in Negril you can't go wrong with the ocean view suites at Banana Beach. I think you might surprised and really be glad to you have the kitchen with microwave, dishes, refrigerator etc when you end up bringing back half your dinner from the great restaurant there. Especially the Brazilian Rodecio (spelling?). It's really nice to open the french doors to the the private balcony overlooking the sea. The rooms are very airy and spacious with some beautiful art and comfortable seating. The staff is great and it's quiet there. There is a travel shop on site that can help you with snorkel and/or other trips.