Wes, well said and reasoned. It gets tiring to read the ad nauseum (and sometimes nasty) retorts to a visitor who doesn't like the island. For every one that doesn't, there are 20 more that do... and therein lies some of the problem.
The growth of all the condos, resorts, etc. is a double edged sword, but something that ultimately happens in any desirable place to go/live. In my opinion, there is far too much building and ultimately encroachment on the natural beauty of the island.
Winston, you should give the mainland a look see, there are many fabulous, stunningly gorgeous places to see and things to do, with costs not so prohibitive. Going to just one place in a country is hardley a basis to judge it.