Thanks everyone for all your replies to my pondering about where to stay. I just finalized our plans and we'll be staying at the Victoria-House. They had a discount for one free night and also booked our island flights from Belize Intl. We are so excited. Ambergise Caye sounds even more appealing after reading the message boards from so many nice locals... You have really outdone yourself with this message board, it's so informative and welcoming. Thanks again!!
See you in Belize