Originally posted by f095:
How hard were the bones to catch. Who took you out? We will be there next and are looking forward to some great fishing.
That depends on your ability or how quickly you can adapt if you've never fished Bones. It also assumes that you're talking about fly fishing, which is what I was doing. This is only my second try at Bonefish, with the first being in Andros two years back. I've done a lot of saltwater fly fishing for other species though, with Bones and Permit being the toughest. The hardest part is seeing them. When they say these things are ghosts, or chameleons, they're not kidding. I really couldn't start seeing them myself until about the middle of the second day. One of the hardest things to deal with is the fact that they appear to change color instantly as they move from surface to surface, and once you lose them, it's hard to find them again. You often see the nervous water, their shadow, or a flash just slightly different from the water glistening in the sun before ever seeing the fish itself. I think I hooked up on 1 out of every 12 shots. The other part is distance and accuracy. You don't have to shoot 70-80' like they say(although you will definitely get plenty of shots at them that far), but you do have to be fairly accurate. I spooked them time after time just from lining them (shooting too far and getting the fly line too close to them).
As far as guides go, I wouldn't think twice about using Severo Guererro again
servero@btl.net . I've done a lot of guided trips in fresh and saltwater, and aside from his expertise, he's one of the most knowledgeable and courteous guides I've known. He put me on top of about 60 Tarpon in one day, hundreds of Bones, and even 15-20 Permit. He can not only spot these fish from hundreds of yards away, he can see exactly what they're doing underwater as he guides your retrieval rate. Even if you can't see them, he can guide your cast so well and tell you when to drop the fly that you stand a good chance even if you can't see them yourself. He'll also get you close if you can't shoot fly line long enough or you're in a bad postion against the wind. This is especially important if he has to guide you on a backcast shot.
A few things I really liked about fishing with Severo is that he'll move or advise you try something different if he senses it doesn't look good. He's excellent at positioning the boat for your best cast. Sometimes he'll follow the fish for quite a while at a distance until he can get in on the right angle. I've been with plenty of guides that will just move in immediately and spook fish many times.
We used a lot of the fly patterns that I brought, but of those, my Orvis-made Cowen's Bonefish Scampi in #8 pink(shallow bead-chain eye) worked the best. One thing I would do differently is make my own flies. Severo had me get him some clear Larva Lace body material, which I found out he uses on his own flies. It gives a Bonefish fly a translucent 3D look. With the rabbit fur, it looked pretty darn close to the Cowen's Bonefish Scampi as well, but it had that extra dimension about it. He let me try it and they tore it up. I've never seen or heard of anyone using that material on a Bonefish fly.
The most important piece of advice I can give you is to make sure you bring a good pair of Polarized sun glasses in med to dark Amber or Vermillion(rose colored) and a cheap backup pair. You can't catch them on these flats unless you can see them, and if you break or lose a pair, you'll be helpless.
Hope that helps. If you have any questions about what gear to bring, let me know. Good luck.