My trips since 2002: Tortola BVI, Aruba (twice), Hopkins (honeymoon), Corozal, San Pedro, Roatan (twice).
Trips booked for next 12 months: Panama, Corozal/San Pedro (split), Roatan.
On my 'to-do' list: Placencia, Isla Holbox (Mexico), Utila.
I was initially concerned that San Pedro might be too commercial, something I was starting to try to get away from. However on the way to Corozal there was a stopover in San Pedro, and sitting there at BCs looking out at the sea I knew I'd be back.