I have been to Caye Caulker 2 times on day trips - and both times I noted - the cut gets packed (well maybe not packed) with people - and it was fun to hang at the bar - and that the "front" street had lots of people selling lots of stuff including bbq that looked and smelled good! I ate at the happy lobster and some pizza place - and had ice cream - everything was good - esp. the happy lobster. I did notice people selling fruit on the street but not fish or meat - only cooked fish. I am sure you will have a great time.

SeeShell (p.s. I will be in San Pedro in April day tripping to Caye Caulker)