I think the choice between them will come down to personal taste as both are very different style. They are both in the Top 10 and perhaps Top 5 of almost everyones Resorts on the Caye.

I can't see the above posters point of view though. There are only two built up property boundaries to the North and South, as the other two are a road at the back and the beach on the front. To the North is another resort. South there are the two houses on either side of Northern Front Street. That would have to be some set of lungs on a baby to travel through ~100 feet of solid concrete building to the pool.