Phil, while I agree in part with what your saying and that swimmers should be afforded some right of way in certain areas, I have to respectfully disagree about a total premptory swimmers right of way; particularly when it comes to swimmers far beyond what would be considered the normal scope of recreational swimming activity as was the case here.

The people were well offshore in the "normal" commercial travel zone if you will, and although the skipper, any skipper for that matter, should always be alert, a Captian should be allowed certain expectations of freedom of operative movement in such areas, particularly while in their own "freeway" so to speak.

To reuse my overly pimped freeway analogy that's why you see "No Pedestrians" signs at the entrance to freeway's. Admittedly the freeways on the waterways are different in terms of the medium and navigation but the analogy of a pedestrian being given right of way to wander about a 65 MPH freeway where, from a safety standpoint, they simply shouldnt be in the first place seems well, somewhat silly and/or impractical at best. Given that the water conditions were choppy that day and made spotting swimmers behind the chop even more difficult, consider adding a dose of fog to that wandering pedestrian analogy.

Ed's story above doesnt surprise me, there are hotdogs in cars and hotdogs in boats and there always will be, just as there will always be people who despite our best efforts to educate them or afford them "right of way" will behave with an astounding lack of common sense.

I agree with Elbert, can you imagine how that skipper felt? Christ I cant even imagine that. I've mentioned it previously and often and I'll throw in with him on that sentiment regarding the skipper today as well. I'm proabably a bit more charitably inclined towards the victim because as I see a gross failure from the standpoint of their education.

As to my overall stance, its a problem that needs to be addressed on both sides. From our own perspective we're going to start with our own guests and make sure they fully understand the concepts and dangers that are in play while swimming or snorkeling on the waters of the inner reef. You can give a swimmer all the right of way you want but they still have to excerise a modecum of common sense in areas where boats travel.

First and foremost we intend to impress the urgency of this matter on our guests. I start with our guests because I have some significant ability to have immediate contact with them. I do not have access or immediate contact with the numerous skippers licensed (hoepfully) or otherwise. I will be providing small hi vis "diver down" floats for our guests to use while snorkeling in and about our dock areas. As to the offshore areas of the inner reef commonly used for high speed boat traffic it will be impressed on our guests that those areas are indeed freeways and reserved for the operation of those vessels at those speeds. In fact I intend to start by saying that beyond the end of our dock its simply "playing in the road" and "dont play in the road". Our little local dive operator will be more than happy to provide a safe means of exploring offshore areas of the inner reef better suited to their safety and enjoyment.

Having said all this about our guests I would simply say that skippers should always keep in mind that people are, generally speaking, amazingly naive (stupid) at times and swimmers of that mental capacity may be, no, make that will be present in their boating lanes at some point. Constant vigilence is needed but even then the unthinkable may happen.