and I'll simply mimic your response Phil and say that I too was speaking in general terms. I never said the victims of this case were stupid nor that I had no sympathy for them (please go back and look at my previous posts). I'd appreciate a bit more care when paraphrasing, thanks.
I was saying that in general people can be naive (even stupid) about the hazards present in an environment with which they are not familar; that they need to have those hazards impressed upon them in order for them to safely recreate. I see the cross section of humanity in my work everyday and much of the time I am not overly impressed by an abundance of common sense in people presented with unfamiliar situations. To date we have no idea what the couple were thinking, their "habitus mentis", their state of mind. How they found themsleves where they were, or if they even considered boat traffic beofre swimming out, what was their destination. That information is key and missing here. If a lawsuit is pending (independent of the BPA investigation findings) it may be years before that information is made public in discovery if at all.
Given the variability in humans, tourists and guest, when it comes to common sense, boat captains also need to be sutiably impressed and imprinted that nowadays their navigable waters are increasingly populated with these kinds of people, people who may simply not know any better. They need to be vigilent for both the swimmer and their own sake. Ways and means for boats to safely operate, with practicality, and in confidence and commerce, needs to be part of the solution as well, and that may require legisaltion down the road. But it needs to be well thought out legislation and get to the heart of the matter and only if it is determined there is a need (whether actual or politcal).
I think there is more common ground between us than you might think but I also happen to think that really digging into the specifics of this case would give you some additional perspective and add to that concensus. What I most typically have repsonded to in this thread are blanket statements and judgements which make little sense based on the facts of the case. Such as statements above that a reckless captain cut a swimmers leg off close to a dock, when that plainly was not the case, or suggestions to require boats on plane to be double the distance offshore from the end of the closest dock; what about when the next dock up or down coast might be 70 yards shorter or farther out. Then what?. Similarly blanket statements of a swimmer should always be given right of way. I'm simply perplexed by that statement? What exactly does that mean? or entail?
Would one think that a skipper upon seeing a swimmer in his immediate path, even far offshore, would even consider who has or needs right of way? "Aha! that swimmer does not have legal right of way so I'll just run his ass over!" Hell no! Given the circumstances and means availabe he's going to do everything in his power to avoid hitting that person. But suppose a swimmer is inside that double dock distance area established for boats by your own rule and we're now under the "swimmers have ultimate right of way law" and the person gets hit? Is it the Captian's fault even then? What about under conditions of poor visiblity? When is the swimmer to be held accountable for his or her actions? Or perhaps better stated, when are the swimmers actions so agregious as to preclude fault on the part of the captain? I think you've just not thought it through all the way. But I also get youre thinking with your heart.
If you want to say "hey I think the water taxis from Belize City are in way too close and always have been" or "we need to create a traffic channel exclusive to planing boat traffic inside the reef" I wouldnt have much to stand on, or argue with, and I'd be left to opine on those proposals.
If you want to propose a navigation channel as far offshore as you deem necessary by all means do so; but define it on the basis of bouys not something as variable as the nearest or farthest dock end. If you want to do something for swimmer safety get involved in promoting SPTC guest education so that when they're not in any established "boat free swimming areas" (as you've been proponing, which I commend and support) they will have the good and kind sense to stay the hell out of areas where boat traffic is fast and heavy, and at least be alert to the presence of boats.
But please when you start asking for and proposing incomplete and half thought out regulations because of a personal injury where the skipper was found free of fault, clearly in his normal course, under conditions of poor surface visibilty, it's going to get my goat everytime. Having written and enforced regulations all my career I can smell the beginnings of a bad one, even one conceived with the best of intentions, a few nautical miles off.
I'm still with Elbert; this case has been tried by the public acting as judge jury and executioner with little attention paid to the facts. I feel deeply for the couple (on their honeymoon no less) that were so seriously injured. It was life altering. However, I also have it in my mind to think of a man doing his job whom, by all official records and accounts was legally, and to the best of his abilities and circumstances, putting food on his family's table, who may now be pariah and just as "crippled" by it all within his own community. That's also a tragedy in its own right because if he did lose his job and wasn't at fault, why did that happen?
I got your back Phil. I can appreciate your concerns and your passion, really I do, but doggonit this all needs to be carefully thought out from a practical and effective standpoint on both sides of the issue.