Thank you all for the feedback. What about Caye Casa as a quiet, yet close place in town? TA has good reviews, but I am still open to suggestions.

I am thinking we may need to do 4 nights at each. Now, which one first???

I am going to have to really bribe the grandparents to watch my kids...twin toddlers and a 10 year old. But I am not above begging!!!

Keep the info coming!
Beth