You KNOW we can NOT narrow it down to just 5!! Here are my favorites

Capricorn's (best steak on the island)
Victoria House (naniamo bars and grilled lobster)
Celi's (chicken strips and fajitas)
BC's BBQ (need I say more?)
Jambel's Jerk Pit (jalepeno alfredo is addictive)
Sweet Basil's (salad)
Caliente's (anything for lunch and their coconut shrimp)
Jade Garden (egg rolls and cheesecake)
Shark's Bar (pizza)
Elvi's (for the experience)
Estel's (breakfast)
Tropical Take out (across from Tropic Air)
Cafe Ole (GREAT pasteries and coffee)
Street Vendors (burritos, rice & beans, anything you want...delicious)
Holiday Hangover Bar (CEVICHE!!! Best on the island)

Sorry, no comment on Papi's and Blue Water Grill. They are on my list to visit though. Oh, and so will the new restaurant/bar that is opening at Banana Beach...sounds mouth watering already!