Yes I am here now - the BYC is perfect!!! Huge rooms, with living area and separate bed-room, living area has kitchenette, and satellite TV. A short walk to Ramons (2min) where the beach is nice and I swam with a stingray just off their pier - not one of those little ones you see every-time you swim... I mean this one was nearly a meter wide... awesome. The pool at the BYC is always clean and the grounds are manicured to perfection. Plus people at Ramons are paying 3-4 times the price as we are here - from what I heard from people I talked to.
I cannot comment on the friendliness of the staff as I have not had cause to go into the reception area. I am always greeted with a pleasant "good morning" when I walk by the grounds keepers/ security guards/ swim-up bartender though. I can't comment on the food either, as I can not justify paying the prices of any of the resort hotel restaurants on AC, but I have seen people eating there and they look pleased. All in all, I am laughing that I almost changed my booking based on what I was reading online. After this trip, if I ever come back to AC, I will stay here again