AmbergrisCaye.com Home Forums The Cayes Environment Offshore Oil Exploration Starts Ruffling Feathers

Investors say 'drill baby drill' but San Pedranos say no to oil prospectors

The international news has been replete with the horrors of the massive oil spill off the Gulf of Mexico. Eighty-five thousand barrels have spilled so far since the well exploded on April twentieth. Oil exploration is a relatively new industry for Belize and while the operations on land have so far experienced no major accidental disasters, offshore drilling is an entirely new experiment for us. But now there is word that a group of investors have been given a license to explore off the coast of San Pedro. That is why San Pedranos are concerned that an oil spill could spell disaster for the entire country. Marion Ali reports from San Pedro.

Marion Ali, Reporting

While oil exploration will earn the country much-needed revenues, the repercussions of a disaster such as a spill like what happened in the Gulf of Mexico, could pose even greater long-term risks for a developing country like Belize, and concerned groups feel there needs to be a reactive solution in place.

Miguel Alamilla, Mgr., Hol Chan Marine Reserve

"Look at what’s happening in the Gulf, they haven't been able to contain that spill for how long? I think it's about two weeks or more. And the US has a lot of resources and money to do that and they haven't been able to do it. What if that would happen here in Belize? It would be an even worse scenario because we have less resources and less finances to be able to contain a leak of that magnitude. Oil exploration can lead to damaging effects. If there is a leak, can we contain that leak? What are the possibilities? What are the possibilities? What are the damages that can result from that? We need to look into that and if something happened it could affect our livelihood, not only for us in San Pedro but for the country, all those that are dependent on tourism."

Elito Arceo, President, Ambergris Caye Citizens for Sustainable Dev.

"Anytime you have an oil exploration offshore San Pedro, they call the document it says very near Ambergris Caye. If you have any oil spill, you’re creating a problem that I’m not even an expert at but my point is, how yoh wah even start to get some measures to actually clean it? What will we do here in Belize? This is our jewel. For any oil spill to happen here and it goes all in our beaches or in the rivers, in all that mangrove ecosystem. How we wah clean dat? With a sponge and squeezy?"

And because the project can have serious and irreversible environmental repercussions, Tourism Minister and Area Representative, Manuel Heredia says he thinks the project needs a second review.

Manuel Heredia, Minister of Tourism/San Pedro Area Rep.

"We have to be very, very cautious, look at it particularly now go back and visit it and see exactly if that is the way we want to go. I usually base my concerns as to what the technical people have to say. Again, if there are concerns from the environmental people, let us sit down and look at it carefully and only and only then should we go ahead and move forward. It's not late yet, exploration has not started so we need to sit down and address it, that would be my personal opinion."

Marion Ali

"But they already have permits. They have already been given approval permits."

Manuel Heredia

"Yes, I will agree that probably they have been given them but looking at the concerns that are happening right now not far away from us, let us look at it, get together with the people and a little more consultation."

Marion Ali

"While the people of San Pedro agree that the fragile tourism industry needs to be enhanced if it is to keep up with a fiercely competitive region, they also believe that the sensitive natural environment needs to be protected; and they are calling on the local authorities to do just that - striking a balance between sustainable tourism development and safeguarding the natural resources for generations to come. Reporting from San Pedro for News Five, Marion Ali."

With all due respect to the ancient Chinese culture, I have to say what I think about the current one (culture).

Present-day China has a horrific record on human abuse, environmental abuse and animal abuse.
If you want to see what happens when the Chinese begin to harvest natural resources, take a look at the rape and pillage of Tibet's fragile ecosystem.

The concept is MADNESS - CRIMINAL HOMICIDAL MADNESS

Marty - can you also post this to the Business Forum - as stakeholders we need to get our fannies in gear on this - it's the worst flipping thing on the planet. Why not just nuke the place and be done with it. YES I AM SHOUTING.

Manuel Heredia - "Yes, I will agree that probably they have been given them [approval permits] but looking at the concerns that are happening right now not far away from us, let us look at it, get together with the people and a little more"

It's hard to reconcile the two sides of Heredia's position. He's not some third party observer, for heaven's sake, he's a Government Minister!

Reading with DISMAY that permits have been issued for drilling exploration offshore of Ambergris Caye Glovers Reef and Stan creek Areas

If they are able to do that and an accident like whats happened in the gulf happens that's the end of Ambergris Caye Period

The way the winds blow will send any spillage right onto the shores of Ambergris Caye and there is no way the island or even country could clean up a spill of that magnitude.

Gaz

I already see the price erosion on real estate market in Ambergris Caye driven from economics, crime and pollution.

The moment they start drilling, the price will drop and they international tourism will looking for a real eco friendly tourism destination.

Belize will be one of the poorest country in central America without tourism and a spoiled nature. But greedy politicians will always find a nice place too spend there money.

Is this how it will end reaching 30 years of independence?

Offshore oil will be the death-knell for Belize. Even if it is struck in significant quantities, no value from it will benefit the country and people of Belize - it'll all be siphoned off in one way or another by "businessmen" or politicians (but I repeat myself). And when (not if) there's a major accident, the investors and the moneyed will simply walk away.

The corruption here is unstoppable, because there isn't a mass movement to stop it. It permeates all levels of life here. If it continues, Belize will indeed sink into the morass of poverty and no-one will want to come here once the physical attractions have gone. As the poverty increases so will the crime. If we're lucky we'll end up like Jamaica or Trinidad, relatively wealthy countries with severe crime problems, but more likely we'll end as poor as our poorest Central American neighbours, because there's virtually no value-adding industry here and no money left to create it - it's all been stolen. Once the ex-pats walk away, abandoning their by-then valueless properties, and no more come because there's nothing to bring them, what then?

Issued to who?

Look on the bright side, all them oil men coming to San Pedro to party.

BrusselSprout and others - Check the "news" section of this message board for the article that discusses this item.
Then start writing letters - we can stop it. In fact with the mess in the Gulf right now, we have an excellent chance of people listening and saying NO to offshore drilling.