Have a great first trip! Xanadu is very nice - small, quiet, good deals, great pool. Another nearby place with lots for the price is Caribbean Villas - only 10 rooms and suites. The rooms are quite economical and you get the quietness, long-time staff great service, 2 acres, wildlife, beach, pier, etc. They are usually booked up early, so I don't know if you could still get in there. About a 12 minute walk to town for both Caribbean Villas and Xanadu.